»
S
I
D
E
B
A
R
«
Phonics vs. Sight Words
Mar 6th, 2010 by mcary

Should sight words be exclusively taught above phonics? I see the importance of these base words being learned by repetition, but my son’s K-5 teachers ONLY use sight words. My son had been working with me at home with phonics for over a year, but we stopped for a month when school began. It wasn’t until he stopped trying to sound words out that we decided to go back to our phonetic pronunciations and lessen his dependence on the sight words. I don’t know how to tell his teacher that phonics works best for him. Am I doing the right thing by continuing to teach him an alternative path to reading? *

Sight words need to be taught in conjunction with phonics. It’s important that beginning readers are able to automatically recognize sight words, but without a sound background in phonics they will never be able to sound out unfamiliar words. As a teacher of beginning readers, I always stress a strong a background in phonics for all levels of students, accompanied by many lists of sight words to be learned over the course of the year.

I’d suggest that you arrange a conference with your son’s teacher. She may be focusing on sight words at this time, but I would be very surprised if phonics are not being used at all in his classroom. In the meantime, keep up what you’re doing. It sounds like phonics are working well for you . Remember, the more decoding strategies your son is able to utilize, the stronger a reader he will become.

*This is a question I’ve paraphrased from a comment I’ve posted from a reader. As teaching reading is such a key issue, I’ve answered here where the response is more visible. For the entire comment and question, please go to the comment section following, “All About Learning Sight Words.”

Related Posts:

Phonemic Awareness and Reading Readiness
Nov 22nd, 2009 by mcary

I am looking for some help.  Recently I attended an Open House at my daughter’s school.  The kindergarten teacher mentioned the skills that children would be working on during the year.  She didn’t get into specifics in each area.  One thing that she mentioned was, “phonemic awareness.”  I am not sure what that is or how I can help my daughter.  If you have any suggestions, I would appreciate the help.

To put it simply, phonemic awareness is the ability to hear and manipulate sounds (or phonemes) in spoken language as they relate to written language.  It is not to be confused with phonics which is a code to sound out written words.  I like to describe phonemic awareness in young children as their ability to hear, use, and understand the rhyme and rhythm in our speech.

Phonemic awareness improves children’s ability to read, spell and comprehend what is read.  I’ve noticed a decline in the phonemic awareness of many children entering school over the past few years.  One reason may be that many parents have gotten away from reading nursery rhymes to their children.  As a result, children often come to school not knowing any rhymes at all.  Repetitive poems and simple rhymes  such as those found in Mother Goose Nursery Rhymes are helpful in teaching phonemic awareness.

Parents should start teaching phonemic awareness when their child is a toddler so that they will have the pre-reading skills they need when they begin school.  Practicing phonemic awareness should be a fun and easy activity.  Here are a few simple games that parents can play with their child whenever they might have a few free minutes.  As most activities do not require a paper and pencil, you can practice (play) them anywhere, even in the car.

PHONEMIC AWARENESS activities include:

1) RHYMING

Recognizing rhymes in books and poems – Read a rhyming book or poem and have the child pick out the rhyming words at the end of each line.

Saying rhymes – Example: “Which two words rhyme: The silly fox sat on the box?”

Recognizing rhymes – Example: “Do these words rhyme: down/dip; down/clown?”

Generating rhymes – Example: “Can you think of a word that rhymes with frog?”

As many other games in this piece, the above are great car games that the whole family can join in on.

2) SEGMENTING SYLLABLES

Say aloud and clap the syllables in words – Example: “How many syllables are in the words: cat; cupcake; elephant; television; etc.?

3) BEGINNING SOUND SUBSTITUTION

Change the first sound of the word to make a new word – Examples:

Ask:  “What would I do to change the word cat to mat?”

“What would I do to change the word cook to shook [harder]?”

“Can you think of a word that rhymes with sock, but starts with an /l/?”

4) TEACHING SOUNDS IN ISOLATION

Identify individual sounds in words – Examples:

“What sound do you hear at the beginning of the word hen?”

“What sound do you hear in the middle if the word pig?”

“What  is the ending sound of lion?”

“What sound do all of these words begin with: duck; dog; damp?”

“What do these words end with: sock; quack; kick?”

Identify words from individual sounds – Examples:

Slowly stretch out the sounds in the word: c / a / t.  Then ask, “What word am I saying?”

Slowly stretch out the sounds in the word: j / u / m / p.  Then ask, “What word am I saying?”

When your daughter has mastered easier concepts, make your games a little harder, move onto higher level skills.  Examples: “Can you say cat without the /C/ ?’  “Can you say brook without the /Br/ ?

By practicing these simple activities with your daughter, you will be helping her master phonemic awareness, an important skill in learning to read!

Related Posts:

»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa
Rss Feed Tweeter button Facebook button Reddit button Delicious button Digg button Stumbleupon button